Always Let Your Bible Be Your Guide

It’s not wise to allow movies to inform our theology. I grew up with the Jiminy Cricket quote: “Always let your conscience be your guide.” In the children’s movie Pinocchio, Disney’s dapper cricket danced and sang, encouraging the wooden puppet—along with the magical Blue Fairy—to follow his conscience as a moral compass for life. “Take the straight and narrow path,” Jiminy sang, “and always let your conscience be your guide.”

Was Jiminy right?

Culturally, the conscience is thought to help with decisions, and the conscience is considered to be rooted in good morals and virtuous character. Yet in colleges today, morals and ethics students debate what good “morality” looks like, and practical applications are open to interpretation.

A guiding conscience, in some situations, is more like a “be true to yourself” mantra than a moral compass for choosing what is proper, moral, or right.

Following True North

When hiking, if our compass is only one degree off course, we likely won’t arrive at our destination. A good, functional compass won’t be skewed; it will point “true north.”

The Christian’s moral compass points “true north” to the Truth of the Bible. God’s Word is the foundation for the believer’s moral and ethical behavior, and consequences are serious when our moral compass is not correctly aligned with God’s Word.

The Westminster Confession says, “God alone is Lord of the conscience.” God has freed us from submission to “doctrines and commandments of men” that are contrary to Scripture, that go beyond His commands or conflict with His wisdom principles for living.

God’s Word must reign supreme in our conscience! Our moral compass must be captive to biblical truth, not the whims of culture or even the fluctuating leanings of our hearts. As Andy Naselli wrote, “That voice in your head is not necessarily God’s voice. Sometimes your conscience may be theologically incorrect.”

In the Bible, Adam and Eve were the first ones to follow their own conscience, but their moral compass was not aligned with God’s words—His clear command (Gen. 2:17; 3:3, 6). The result was disastrous! Deceived, their human conscience allowed them to make a faulty, rebellious choice.


Following our conscience can get tricky, especially in relation to others. Sometimes God calls us to “recalibrate” our conscience in order to encourage believers.

A Christian man I know came out of a rough and sinful “bar scene.” As a new believer, he showed spiritual growth in many areas, but he still struggled with some tough memories. A certain kind of music reminded him of those sinful days and opened him up to temptation. Because fellow believers loved that man in Christ, they chose, in his presence, not to play the kind of music that wounded his spirit. His friends showed great maturity, sensitivity and deference.

In the New Testament, Paul often urged Christians to be sensitive and non-judgmental in matters of conscience within the family of God. In two cases, Paul mentioned being sensitive to those who value certain days over others or abstain from certain foods or wine. We need to be especially sensitive to new or young believers who have a “weak conscience.”

Sometimes a “weak conscience” stems from a believer’s past experiences with legalism or a different religious culture. Other times—like the Christian who came out of the “bar scene”—a weak conscience comes from struggles with long-standing temptation or memories from their years before coming to know Christ.

Andy Naselli writes about Christians’ need to “recalibrate” when it’s clear something isn’t necessarily taboo for them but it is a “stumbling block” to others following Christ. We wisely need to be more proactive about clearing our conscience in those cases, but the first step is to recognize when we have offended or hindered someone.

We often recalibrate spiritually as God changes our perspective. We choose to follow the direction and Lordship of Jesus in matters of conscience (Mark 7:18–19; Rom. 14:17; 1 Cor. 8:8), even when it doesn’t make sense to us. We see an example of this when Peter, in a vision from God, revolted against eating forbidden animals, but then he recalibrated his conscience (Acts 10:9–16) after a voice from heaven said to him, “What God has made clean, do not call common.” Perhaps in that vision Peter understood a connection to gospel outreach. He, like the other disciples, initially struggled with Jesus reaching out to the Gentiles (John 4:1–42; Matt. 15:22–30). But over time, observing the Master, the disciples and ultimately the Body of Christ recalibrated their thinking. They began to understand the Savior’s mission and their assignment (Mark 16:15): The gospel message was for Jews, Gentiles and “everyone who believes” (Rom. 1:16).

Doubting, Damaging, or Defiled

In recent days, I’ve examined my conscience to see where it might not be in line with Scripture. When faced with a choice of conscience, I try to ask three questions.

1. Is there some shred of doubt?

Romans 14:23, addressing the issue of eating “forbidden” foods, notes: “Whatever does not proceed from faith is sin.” In the broader sense, whatever choice in my walk with God is not agreeable to the Scriptures—the Word and doctrine of faith—should not to be pursued. Without faith, I cannot please God (Heb. 11:6).

As I walk in faith, I must be aware that sometimes another Christian’s walk may look entirely different from mine. God may give them different marching orders. This is the “Others May, You Cannot” concept. Be careful in matters of the conscience not to disdain what God has allowed for others. Give grace!

At the same time, to ignore or disobey the Holy Spirit’s caution or direction to us is to sin against Him and our conscience.

2. Is there some way my choice might damage others?

Paul addressed the question of certain things being lawful for believers. But what if they are not the most helpful or edifying choice? Something might be lawful for me, but will my choice wound another Christian’s soul?

I want to be careful not to hinder another believer’s walk with God (Rom. 14:13, 21; 1 Cor. 8:12–13; 10:32).

I don’t want my choices, even if I am free to make them, to become a “stumbling block” to a weaker believer, hurting their conscience and possibly hindering them from fully following Christ.

3. Is my choice somehow defiled by sinful desires?

In other words, does my choice line up with the perfect and holy Word of God? Is my conscience clean and clear by God’s standards?

The Bible speaks of unbelievers who profess to know God, but by their deeds they deny Him. Their internal radar is “corrupted” or defiled (Titus 1:15–16). Some even have a conscience so defiled the Bible describes it as “seared” or rendered insensitive to sin, not working properly (1 Tim. 4:1–2).

But God’s Spirit works to transform the conscience of those who have placed their trust in Christ and have new life in Him. I need to cooperate with the Holy Spirit in this transformation and maintain a clean and clear conscience so sin will not interfere. As Timothy exhorts believers: Hold on to faith and a “good conscience.”

Realign Your Conscience Daily

John MacArthur writes, “For a conscience to be trustworthy, it must be programmed with scriptural teaching.”

At one point in my Christian journey, when my conscience was terribly weak and I desperately needed to stop justifying my sin and realign my conscience with the Word of God, I decided I wanted to have a conscience void of offense toward God and others. God called me deeper into His Word. He slowly showed me sins that weakened and corrupted my conscience and hindered my prayers and ministry.

A conscience “void of offence” means knowing there is no unconfessed sin between God and us, and that “we can look everyone we know in the eyes without shame and know that we are right with them, insofar as it depends on us” (Seeking Him). Jesus takes personally what we do or say to others (Matt. 25:37–40, 45).

As we approach the Scriptures humbly—asking the Spirit of God to point out any area where we have sinned against the Lord or wounded others with our attitudes, words or actions—the Spirit will be faithful to reveal the truth. John MacArthur wrote, “A conscience isn’t designed to be our guide; it is a tool of the Guide.”

It is our needful duty to realign our conscience with His Word and continue to speak God’s Truth into our lives. It is also our responsibility to stay sensitive to the Spirit and do whatever is required to gain a clear conscience with others (Matt. 5:23–24). Pray daily for a strong conscience.

Jiminy Cricket didn’t go far enough. Letting our conscience be our guide is only good advice when our hearts are saturated with Scripture and we walk in step with the Spirit of God.

About the Author

Dawn Wilson

Dawn Wilson

Dawn Wilson has served in revival ministry and missions for more than 50 years. Dawn assists Nancy DeMoss Wolgemuth with research and works with various departments at Revive Our Hearts. She is the founder and director of Heart Choices Today, … read more …

Join the Discussion